Introduction

Advocate AK Tiwari - Transfer Petition in Supreme Court and Allahabad High Court is a legal recourse available to a litigant who seeks to move their case from one court to another within the jurisdiction of a superior court. The necessity of filing a transfer petition arises from various factors such as convenience of parties, jurisdictional conflicts, threat to life, undue influence, and fair trial considerations. In India, transfer petitions can be filed both in the Supreme Court and the High Court, depending on the nature of the case and the jurisdiction involved.

Legal Basis for Transfer Petitions

The legal framework for transfer petitions in High Courts and the Supreme Court is provided under different statutory provisions:

1. Under the Constitution of India
   • Article 226: Provides the High Court with the power to issue certain writs, but not specifically for transfer of cases.
   • Article 227: Empowers the High Court to exercise supervisory jurisdiction over subordinate courts and tribunals.
2. Under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC)
   • Section 22: Allows for the transfer of a suit from one civil court to another upon application by a party.
   • Section 23: Lays down the provisions for when cases can be transferred between courts under different jurisdictions.
   • Section 24: Empowers the High Court to transfer cases from one subordinate court to another within its jurisdiction.
3. Under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC)
   • Section 407: Grants the High Court the power to transfer criminal cases from one subordinate criminal court to another within the state.
   • Section 408: Allows the Sessions Court to transfer criminal cases within its jurisdiction.

When Can a Transfer Petition Be Filed in the High Court?

A transfer petition can be filed in the High Court in the following circumstances:

1. Civil Cases
   • When there is apprehension of bias or undue influence in the lower court.
   • When there is a question of territorial jurisdiction.
   • When transferring the case ensures convenience to parties and witnesses.
   • When the interest of justice demands the case be heard in another court.
2. Criminal Cases
   • When the accused or witnesses face threats in the existing court jurisdiction.
   • When the fair trial is at risk due to local influence.
   • When the prosecution or defense is hindered due to geographical constraints.
3. Matrimonial and Family Cases
   • When a spouse, especially the wife, finds it difficult to attend proceedings due to distance.
   • When there is a risk of harassment or undue pressure from the opposite party.
   • When child custody or maintenance cases require adjudication in a different jurisdiction for the welfare of the minor.

Procedure for Filing a Transfer Petition in the High Court

The procedure for filing a transfer petition in the High Court is as follows:

1. Drafting the Transfer Petition:
   • The petition should include details of the case, grounds for transfer, and supporting evidence.
   • An affidavit should be attached, verifying the facts stated.
2. Filing the Petition:
   • The petition is filed in the High Court with jurisdiction over the lower court where the case is currently pending.
   • A requisite court fee must be paid.
3. Issuance of Notice:
   • The High Court may issue a notice to the opposite party and call for their response.
4. Hearing:
   • Both parties present their arguments before the High Court.
   • The court may seek additional evidence or clarification.
5. Final Order:
   • The High Court passes an order either allowing or dismissing the transfer petition.
   • If allowed, the case is transferred to the designated court.

Key Judicial Precedents

Several landmark judgments have outlined the principles governing transfer petitions in the High Court:

1. Maneka Sanjay Gandhi v. Rani Jethmalani (1979) – The Supreme Court held that a case transfer should only be allowed when there is a real likelihood of bias or prejudice.
2. Guda Vijayalakshmi v. Guda Ramachandra Sekhara Sastry (1981) – The court emphasized that in matrimonial cases, the convenience of the wife should be considered while deciding transfer petitions.
3. Subramaniam Swamy v. Ramakrishna Hegde (1990) – The court ruled that public confidence in the judiciary must be upheld, and cases should be transferred if there is a reasonable apprehension of bias.

Limitations and Challenges

While transfer petitions serve an important function in ensuring justice, they also have some limitations:

• Delays in Adjudication: Filing a transfer petition often results in delays in the primary case.
• Burden of Proof: The petitioner must convincingly establish the necessity for transfer.
• Judicial Discretion: High Courts have wide discretion, and subjective considerations may influence the decision.
• Inter-Jurisdictional Challenges: In cases involving transfers across states, the Supreme Court may have exclusive jurisdiction.

Conclusion

A transfer petition can be filed in the High Court under Sections 22, 23, and 24 of the CPC and Sections 407 and 408 of the CrPC, depending on whether the case is civil or criminal. The High Court plays a crucial role in ensuring fair trial and convenience for litigants by transferring cases where necessary. However, the petitioner must establish valid reasons for transfer, balancing the interests of justice and avoiding unnecessary procedural delays.

Ultimately, while the High Court has the power to transfer cases within its jurisdiction, inter-state transfers require intervention by the Supreme Court under Article 139A of the Constitution. Thus, a well-reasoned and justified approach is essential for success in transfer petitions.

AK Tiwari & Associates stands as a pillar of legal excellence in Delhi/NCR. Whether navigating complex corporate transactions, litigating high-stakes disputes, or safeguarding individual rights, the firm remains committed to delivering justice with competence and integrity. As a trusted legal partner, AK Tiwari & Associates continues to uphold the highest standards of the legal profession, making a lasting impact on the legal community and society at large.

Read this also

AK Tiwari & Associates: A Premier Law Firm in Delhi/NCR